In 1999, the
Washington State Legislature asked the Washington
State Office of Public Defense (OPD) to report on
inequalities in attorney funding in dependency and
termination cases. OPD conducted an investigation of
Washington’s juvenile courts, finding severe
disparities between state funding for the Attorney
General’s Office (AGO) for the initiation and
processing of these cases compared to the funds
provided by counties for legal representation of the
indigent parents involved.
In 2000, OPD
sought a legislative appropriation to create an
innovative state-funded enhanced parent
representation pilot program in the Benton-Franklin
and Pierce juvenile courts.
The
Legislature established five program goals to
enhance the quality of defense representation in
dependency and termination hearings:
-
Reduce the number
of continuances requested by attorneys;
including those based on their unavailability;
-
Set maximum
caseload requirements per full-time attorney. In
2003, OPD set the fulltime maximum caseload at
80 open cases per attorney.
-
Enhance defense
attorneys’ practice standards, including
reasonable time for case preparation and the
delivery of adequate client advice;
-
Support the use of
investigative and expert services in dependency
cases; and
-
Ensure
implementation of indigency screenings of
parents, guardians, and legal custodians.
To achieve
these goals, program implementation includes
reasonable compensation for attorneys, reduced caseloads,
access to social worker staff, expert and
investigative resources, periodic attorney
trainings, and oversight of attorneys'
performance.
Since 2000, the program has been continuously
re-funded by the Legislature. The 2005 and 2006
Legislatures provided additional funding to allow
expansion of the Program to Clallam, Clark, Cowlitz,
Ferry, Grant, Grays Harbor, Kitsap, Kittitas,
Pacific, Pend Oreille, Skagit, Snohomish, Spokane,
Stevens and Yakima counties. The 2007 Legislature
appropriated additional monies that funded expansion
of the program to Chelan, Jefferson,
Klickitat, Mason, Skamania, Thurston and Wahkiakum
counties.
The Parents’
Representation Program has succeeded in meeting its
goals, according to evaluations and juvenile court
stakeholder interviews (see, e.g. Northwest
Institute for Children and Families,
Evaluation Report 2005 and
Improving Parents' Representation in Dependency
Cases: A Washington State Pilot Program Evaluation).
It has resulted in better outcomes for children,
including increased family reunifications,
continuance reductions, improved case participation
by parents, and better access to services, among
other benefits. To listen to an audio of parents,
their attorneys, and judicial officers talking about
the program, click
Reuniting More Families.
For further
information about the program’s design and goals,
see
Implementing Equal Justice for Parents in
Washington: A Dual Approach,
published in the Juvenile Justice Journal in 2002. A parallel
statewide effort, the
Dependency and Termination Equal Justice Committee
Report, was a companion system-wide
effort to analyze and improve dependency and
termination court proceedings. The report describes
various recommendations that can be implemented in
conjunction with the Parents’ Representation Program
by juvenile courts interested in increasing the
quality and efficiency of court practices and
processes.